Board Defense for Physician Assistants: What’s Covered, Costs, and How to Respond to a Complaint

Fast links:

• PA Insurance Guide

• PA Cost by State (2025) data

• Arizona Physician Assistant Insurance

• Florida Physician Assistant Insurance

• Pennsylvania Physician Assistant Insurance

• New York Physician Assistant Insurance

• California Physician Assistant Insurance

• Texas Physician Assistant Insurance

• Tennessee Physician Assistant Insurance

• North Carolina Physician Assistant Insurance

• New Jersey Physician Assistant Insurance

Board defense for physician assistants

A board complaint is different from a malpractice lawsuit. It’s administrative—handled by your state PA/medical board—and it targets your license and professional standing. The right PA malpractice policy typically includes board defense for physician assistants, which can cover attorney fees, response prep, interviews, and hearings. Gaps happen when PAs rely only on employer coverage that doesn’t extend to board defense, or when they switch carriers without confirming the endorsement remains.

Why board defense matters (and how it differs from malpractice)

• Malpractice claim → civil litigation seeking money damages.

• Board complaint → regulatory action that can result in reprimands, fines, mandated education, probation, suspension, or revocation.

Even a minor complaint can demand weeks of document review and attorney time. The focus isn’t just indemnity; it’s protecting your license and reputation—and preventing an administrative matter from escalating into malpractice exposure.

What comprehensive board defense for physician assistants often includes

Always review your declarations and endorsements—terms and sub-limits vary by carrier and state.

• License/board defense (administrative hearing expense): Attorney fees and representation for complaints and investigations, including response drafting, interviews, and hearings.

• HIPAA/privacy defense: Help with investigations and proceedings related to alleged privacy or security lapses.

• Deposition & subpoena assistance: Preparation and counsel support if you’re subpoenaed or deposed.

• Loss of earnings/time away: Reimbursement for time off required by defense or proceedings (when included).

• Good Samaritan & related benefits: Protection for volunteer aid and select regulatory hearings that can intersect with board matters.

Watch the sub-limits. Board defense is often capped separately (e.g., several thousand to tens of thousands). Choose a limit that realistically covers attorney time in your state.

What’s usually not covered or needs an add-on

• Fines or penalties the board imposes (varies by policy and jurisdiction)

• Criminal defense (separate from administrative defense)

• Employment disputes (HR actions unrelated to clinical conduct)

• Unlicensed practice or work outside your scope

• Cyber/privacy events beyond HIPAA defense unless you add cyber liability

If you practice telemedicine, work across multiple states, or perform procedures that draw heightened review, confirm those exposures are contemplated and scheduled.

Board defense for physician assistants vs employer coverage

Employer policies primarily protect the employer’s risk. That can mean shared limits, facility-focused definitions of covered services, and limited or no personal board defense—especially for moonlighting, telemedicine, or work outside a single facility.

An individual PA policy follows you across roles (when properly scheduled), states (with the right endorsements), and career changes—so your board defense, HIPAA defense, deposition assistance, and any loss-of-earnings benefits move with you.

What triggers a PA board complaint?

Common triggers

• Patient grievances, outcome concerns, or communication breakdowns

• Privacy incidents (misdirected records, unsecured messages)

• Documentation or prescribing issues

• Scope/delegation disagreements or supervision lapses

• Mandatory institutional reports

Typical process (state procedures vary)

1. Notice of complaint/investigation

2. Request for records + your written response

3. Possible interview or informal conference

4. Board review → dismissal, advisory/caution letter, consent agreement, or hearing

5. Order → CME, proctorship, monitoring, fines, probation, or other terms

Costs: why a meaningful board defense sub-limit matters

Attorney time (records review, strategy, drafting, interviews) is the main cost driver. Straightforward matters can still consume double-digit hours; complex cases or hearings require more. A meaningful board defense sub-limit helps you engage experienced counsel early and stay represented through resolution.

For directional premium expectations on the overall malpractice policy, see the PA Cost by State (2025) data

Response plan: what to do the day a complaint arrives

1. Notify your insurer immediately. Early notice speeds counsel assignment; don’t draft a response letter alone.

2. Preserve and organize records. Pull charts, orders, messages, and follow-up notes. Do not alter anything.

3. Coordinate with assigned counsel. Build the timeline; gather protocols, standing orders, delegation/collaboration agreements, and relevant policies.

4. Craft the written response. Lead with facts, standards, and patient-safety actions. Counsel will calibrate tone and citations.

5. Prepare for interviews/conferences. Role-play the tough questions; reference documents cleanly.

6. Plan remediation where appropriate. Proactively propose CME, policy updates, or supervision changes when it supports resolution.

Prevention: habits that lower board risk

• Clear documentation: assessment, informed consent, patient education, follow-up plans, result tracking.

• Scope & collaboration discipline: current standing orders and supervision/collaboration agreements.

• Escalation playbook: high-risk meds, procedures, or red-flag symptoms trigger documented consult/escalation.

• Patient communication hygiene: avoid ambiguity; summarize next steps; use teach-back.

• HIPAA/privacy rigor: secure messaging; minimum necessary; confirm recipient identity.

Shopping checklist: how to compare board defense for physician assistants

• License/board defense included with a meaningful sub-limit (ideally per claim, not only aggregate)

• HIPAA/privacy defense present; subpoena/deposition assistance specified

• Loss-of-earnings benefit for required appearances (if available)

• Consent-to-settle terms on malpractice; clarity on defense costs inside vs outside limits

• Telemedicine & multi-state coverage options

• Relevant specialty endorsements available (procedures, settings)

• Tail options and retroactive date handling that keep you protected through job changes